Print this review

Der Herr der Ringe - Die Gefährten
The Card Game

Der Herr der Ringe - Die Gefährten

Publisher: Ravensburger

Author: Reiner Knizia

Tester: Aaron Haag

Game Tested: 2001 release

Scenario: Frodo and his friends Sam, Merry and Pippin flee through the towns of Middlearth to prevent Sauron from taken the ring back from him. Two to four players play character cards for each town in order to receive victory points.

The Game: Although designed by the same author this game is not an extension or sequel to the "Lord Of The Rings" game series published by Kosmos/Hasbro. In fact, there is very little reference in the game mechanics to the Lord of the Rings theme and one may assume that Ravensburger decided to use the current LotR hype for marketing reasons only as the game itself is an abstract card-laying game. The cards use photographs of characters of the LotR movie and this may explain the relatively high price.

Up to four players use identical sets of 22 cards to gain control over 10 towns of Middlearth. To do this players in sequence place cards next to the two cards representing a town from their hand. Das KartenspielOf the 22 cards each player receives 6 randomly drawn cards. Once all ten spaces surrounding a town are occupied players earn points depending on their relative strength in that town. Each character card has a value between 0 and 5. Players may play any number of cards valued 1 or one higher valued card. The one card with value 0 and the Nazgûl may be played in addition. All character card values of a player on the cards bordering the currently scoring town are added up and the top scoring players receive the victory points printed on the town card. Additionally, some towns provide a "ring" to the strongest player. Such a ring may be used in subsequent turns to protect a character just played. In addition most rings provide special powers that influence the character cards played in a town or the town itself.

The player who placed the card which initiated the scoring of a town is the first player to place a new town on the table. The two cards of the new town must be placed next to each other and next to already placed character cards. This means that characters can score twice in a game. It is therefore a considerable advantage to place the last card for a town because only then one is able to place the new town cards in a favorable position.

Some towns (black) are more dangerous than others (white) because in black towns stronger character cards may be placed on top of already played cards. And there is the Nazgûl card of which each player has exactly one. The Nazgûl is used to remove an already played card from the table. Frodo (value 3) is however always protected by the ring against being covered up or being removed.

The game ends when either the last (tenth) town has been completed or all but one player have run out of cards.

Playing Time: The game can be explained in about 5 minutes. Playing time is 20 to 45 minutes.

Similar Games: Samurai, Corruption

Westpark Gamer's Opinion: Besides the fact that the game's atmosphere bears no resemblance to LotR whatsoever, which may disappoint players looking exactly for this, "Die Gefährten" is not a bad game at all. Due to the nature of card games there is an element of luck but the game mechanics provide sufficient room for tactics and timing. I personally believe that the game is rather more complex than one may think after one has played it just once or twice - a typical Knizia so to say.

The victory points per town vary from the lesser valued towns (5 points total plus 1 rings) in the beginning to the higher valued towns (13 points) towards the end of the game. Some careful resource management with respect to character cards is asked for here. It is also quite important to keep an eye on the card layout on the table. First, this provides valuable information about the cards other players are still able to play; secondly, one must avoid that one player gains many "high-valued" sides for placing new towns and thirdly, the edge of the table is often approaching faster then one may think. It is a good idea to agree beforehand how this last situation is dealt with - either towns may only be placed where it is possible to play all character cards (not quite to the rules though) or the cards are shifted on the table (not as easy as it sounds). On smaller tables I suggest you move to the floor anyway.

"Finishing" a town by placing a card on the last free space is of a considerable advantage in this game. On the one hand it enables a player to tip the scales in this town by playing a high valued card and gaining higher victory points and on the other hand it enables a player to decide upon the location of the next town. This "double scoring effect" is what makes the game rather complex and which forces the players to carefully think and plan ahead. As a consequence there may be very little player interaction and a lot of thinking and calculating in a group of "serious" gamers.

Aaron's Rating: 6 (out of 10)

Westpark Gamers' Rating: 4

Links to further information: Funagain's page about Der Herr der Ringe - Die Gefährten
Luding link for Der Herr der Ringe - Die Gefährten